One Expert, Less Conflict: How a Single Neutral Expert Can Save Families Time and Money

One Expert, Less Conflict: How a Single Neutral Expert Can Save Families Time and Money

When One Expert Is Better Than Two: How Joint § 730 Experts Can Save Families Time, Money, and Stress

In high-asset or complex family-law cases, it’s common for each spouse to hire their own appraiser, business valuator, or forensic accountant. Each expert reviews the same documents, prepares a separate report, and then cross-examines the other at trial- often at enormous cost. By the end, the parties may have spent more money on the experts than the difference between their two valuations.

California appellate courts have seen this cycle many times and have cautioned against it.

The High Cost of “Dueling Experts”

In In re Marriage of Duncan (2001) 90 Cal.App.4th 617, both spouses hired their own experts to value a closely held business. After years of litigation and two rounds of trial, the court observed that the combined expert and legal fees had nearly eclipsed the disputed difference in value.

Likewise, in In re Marriage of Nichols (1994) 27 Cal.App.4th 661, the court noted that the parties’ “battle of experts” consumed significant resources without materially advancing the result. Each side’s accountant reached a slightly different number, and the trial court simply averaged them—leaving both sides frustrated and financially depleted.

And in In re Marriage of Smith (2015) 242 Cal.App.4th 529, dueling forensic accountants spent years tracing investment accounts, only for the court to find that the fees ultimately outweighed the value of the contested assets.

These cases are reminders that expert warfare rarely serves anyone well.

The § 730 Alternative: A Smarter Path

California Evidence Code § 730 offers an elegant solution. It allows the court to appoint a neutral expert—by stipulation or court order—to investigate, report, and testify on any issue requiring expert evidence.

In family law, § 730 experts are frequently used for:

  • Business valuations and goodwill assessments
  • Tracing separate vs. community property
  • Determining income available for support
  • Real-estate, pension, or stock-option valuations

A § 730 expert’s duty is to the court, not either party. This neutrality reduces duplication and promotes efficiency.

Benefits of a Jointly Retained Expert

  • Lower total cost: The parties share one professional’s fees instead of funding two full analyses.
  • Streamlined process: Only one set of documents, interviews, and reports.
  • Less gamesmanship: The neutral’s role discourages inflated or strategic valuations.
  • Judicial confidence: Judges often give substantial weight to a § 730 expert’s findings because the expert is perceived as objective.
  • Settlement leverage: A single, credible report can form the foundation for negotiation and early resolution.

When properly scoped, a § 730 appointment can turn a combative process into a collaborative one, saving both money and emotional bandwidth.

Practical Considerations

A joint appointment works best when both sides agree on:

  • The expert’s identity and qualifications
  • The precise questions to be answered
  • The timeframe for review and report
  • Cost-sharing arrangements

Even if one side later retains a rebuttal expert under Evidence Code § 733, the neutral’s report provides a common baseline that often narrows the issues and promotes settlement.

Gabriela Ferreira

Family Law Attorney- Santa Barbara & Ventura Counties